I admit that I’ve never given much thought to fantasy baseball draft software. (In fact, I usually just stick to pen and paper.)
However, I took a few minutes to look at what software is currently available. Everything I found offers the same basic functionality–projections, custom rankings, etc. They are also all Windows only.
Here’s what I found, sorted by price:
Diamond Draft – $34.95
Fantistics Insider Baseball – $39.95
RotoWire – $39.99
Rhino Baseball Draft Magic – $59.95
RotoLab – $69.00
I’m actually a little surprised by the prices. I’ll pay $8 for a magazine just to have some light reading, and I’ve even shelled out for the Baseball Forecaster in the past. But I don’t see myself paying $40 for what amounts to the Price Guide + in-draft adjustments.
Which also makes me wonder how the Price Guide’s valuation method stacks up against what is in these programs… From the comparisons I’ve made so far, I think the Price Guide is the best at what it does. You would think that the non-free options would be a step above what’s freely available.
So I’m curious: For those who have tried out these programs, what do you think about them? (And is RotoLab really that much better than the competition?) Am I missing something valuable here?